Understanding the two types of lodging
Lodging is one of the most commercially significant but least predictable risks in cereal production. A crop that stands upright through June may collapse in a single July windstorm, converting a potential 9 t/ha crop into a tangled mat that requires a specialist combine driver and adds hours per field. Separating the two types matters because they require different management responses.
Root lodging — the more common type — occurs when the root plate fails to anchor the plant in soft, wet soil under wind loading. The stem often remains intact, and the plant can partially recover (re-erect), but the grain-filling period is disrupted. Stem lodging (brackling) is a catastrophic failure of the stem itself, typically at the first internode above the soil. Lodged stems rarely recover, and grain fill in affected plants stops effectively. AHDB lodging guidance ↗ covers both with practical management frameworks.
Risk factors
Lodging risk is multiplicative — multiple moderate-risk factors combine to produce a high overall risk. The key factors are:
- Variety standing ability: The most controllable factor. High-yielding varieties often carry weaker stem structure — check AHDB RL lodging scores before variety selection.
- Nitrogen rate and timing: Excess nitrogen produces soft, lush stem tissue early in the season that is both taller and structurally weaker. A large first split in a forward crop is the highest-risk nitrogen decision.
- Plant population: Thick crops produce more mutual shading, taller plants and weaker stems. Overdrilling to compensate for expected losses increases lodging risk if emergence is better than expected.
- Soil type: Light, free-draining soils produce shorter, firmer stems with better anchorage. Heavy, waterlogged soils produce soft growth and poor root anchorage.
- Weather: Warm, wet May–June conditions drive rapid stem elongation; late June windstorms provide the triggering force.
The Rothamsted lodging research programme ↗ developed the Lodge Risk model, which quantifies how these factors combine multiplicatively to produce an overall lodging risk score for planning PGR use.
Growth regulators
Plant growth regulators (PGRs) reduce lodging risk by shortening the lower internodes and increasing stem wall thickness. Chlormequat (applied at GS25–30) and trinexapac-ethyl (applied at GS30–32) are the main UK products. Splitting applications — a priming dose at GS25 followed by a main dose at GS32 — often outperforms a single application in high-risk situations. AHDB growth regulator guidance ↗ provides crop-specific protocols.
PGRs do not compensate for variety weakness or excess nitrogen — they are a risk-reduction tool on top of good agronomy, not a substitute for it.
Harvest implications
A lodged field may cost 30–60 minutes per hectare in combine time compared to a standing crop, and grain moisture will be higher (increasing drying costs). Specific weight is typically reduced — which affects marketability for milling contracts. Managing combine speed, cutting height and reel speed are the key harvesting adaptations. The FarmTheGuide harvest management guide covers harvest strategies in variable crops.