Protect

Fungicide Resistance Management

Fungicide Resistance Management guide.

5 min read · Crops:

FRAC groups relevant to UK cereal fungicides

FRAC groupExamplesResistance riskNotes
FRAC 3 (DMI / triazoles) prothioconazole, tebuconazole, epoxiconazole Medium Polygenic; sensitivity shifts gradual — monitor annually
FRAC 7 (SDHI) bixafen, fluxapyroxad, boscalid High Target site mutations common in Septoria and Ramularia
FRAC 11 (QoI / strobilurins) azoxystrobin, pyraclostrobin Very high Single nucleotide mutation (G143A); Septoria fully resistant
FRAC M (multi-site) chlorothalonil (banned), folpet, mancozeb Very low No recorded target-site resistance; key anti-resistance tool

Five principles for slowing resistance

  1. 1
    Understand the resistance mechanisms in your target pathogen

    Different pathogens develop resistance by different mechanisms. Septoria tritici blotch (Zymoseptoria tritici) accumulates multiple SDHI target site mutations (SDH subunit B, C, D variants) through polygenic selection — sensitivity erodes gradually over seasons. QoI resistance in Septoria is absolute (G143A mutation) — strobilurins have no practical curative activity. Understanding the mechanism determines whether you are managing a gradual shift (still some chemistry value) or an absolute barrier (chemistry is lost). Check AHDB and FRAC annual monitoring reports before finalising programme design.

  2. 2
    Rotate between FRAC groups at every application

    Never apply the same fungicide group twice in succession to the same field or at consecutive timings (T1 and T2). Rotating between FRAC groups — triazole at T1, SDHI + triazole at T2, multi-site at both — reduces selection pressure on any single group. Do not rely on product mixing as a substitute for group rotation: mixing two SDHIs is not better than using one SDHI, because both apply selection pressure to the same target site. Always use the shortest possible application interval that provides economic control — fewer applications reduce cumulative selection pressure.

  3. 3
    Include a multi-site fungicide at key timings

    Multi-site contact fungicides (folpet, mancozeb, thiram) act on multiple biochemical targets simultaneously — resistance by target site mutation is essentially impossible because the pathogen would need to mutate multiple sites simultaneously. Including a multi-site at T1 and/or T2 provides background disease suppression, reduces reliance on SDHIs and slows resistance selection in Septoria and Ramularia. The loss of chlorothalonil (FRAC M5) in 2019 removed the most widely used multi-site in UK cereals — folpet is the primary replacement.

  4. 4
    Use disease-resistant varieties to reduce chemistry dependency

    Variety resistance is the most cost-effective and resistance-proof disease management tool. A variety with a septoria score of 7+ from the AHDB Recommended List typically requires two fewer fungicide applications per season than a variety scoring 4–5. Resistance scores vary by disease — choose varieties with broad-spectrum resistance (septoria, yellow rust, brown rust) rather than relying on chemistry to compensate for susceptibility. Variety resistance does not face the same selection pressure as fungicide chemistry, but it can be overcome by new pathogen races — the UKCPVS monitors this annually.

  5. 5
    Monitor sensitivity and adapt programmes annually

    AHDB publishes annual fungicide performance data from its national fungicide trials network — this is the most reliable source of UK field-level sensitivity data. FRAC publishes global resistance monitoring data including sensitivity shifts in SDHI SDH variant frequencies. Use these data to compare product efficacy year-on-year and adjust programme design before resistance progresses. Growers and agronomists should contribute field samples to AHDB's disease monitoring programme — the network's accuracy depends on broad sampling across UK regions.

The monitoring infrastructure

UK fungicide resistance monitoring is coordinated through AHDB ↗, Rothamsted Research and the Fungicide Resistance Action Committee (FRAC) ↗. Annual pathogen samples from across the UK are tested for sensitivity shifts, and the results inform the guidance issued through AHDB's annual disease management updates.

See the fungicide resistance in Septoria article for the most recent monitoring findings, the barley disease management guide for Ramularia-specific resistance context, and the Septoria tritici blotch glossary entry for pathogen background.

Frequently asked questions

Why do strobilurins (QoIs) no longer work on Septoria?
The G143A mutation in the cytochrome bc1 gene renders the QoI fungicide binding site non-functional for azoxystrobin, pyraclostrobin and other strobilurins. This mutation provides complete, high-level resistance — there is no partial sensitivity or dose–response relationship remaining. The mutation was detected in UK Zymoseptoria tritici populations from 2002 and is now ubiquitous. Strobilurins remain active against some other cereal diseases (brown rust, yellow rust — partial activity), but they should not be included in programmes primarily for Septoria control. FRAC resistance mechanism reports ↗ document the G143A mechanism in detail.
What is SDHI resistance and how quickly is it developing?
SDHIs (FRAC group 7) inhibit the succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) enzyme in the fungal mitochondrial respiratory chain. Resistance develops through point mutations in SDH subunit genes (SdhB, SdhC, SdhD). Unlike the G143A QoI mutation, SDHI resistance in Z. tritici is polygenic — multiple mutations each contributing partial resistance. Sensitivity erodes gradually as resistant allele frequencies increase in populations. AHDB SDHI sensitivity monitoring ↗ tracks annual changes in UK populations. Current AHDB guidance categorises products by risk level and advises maximum applications per season per SDHI active ingredient.
What is the difference between a fungicide programme and a fungicide strategy?
A fungicide programme is the specific sequence of products and timings used in one season on one crop. A fungicide strategy is the multi-year approach to managing resistance across the rotation — including variety selection, programme design, rotation between groups, and contribution to area-wide resistance monitoring. AHDB resistance management guidance ↗ and the WRAG guidelines ↗ cover both levels. Resistance is a shared resource problem — agronomic decisions on one farm affect pathogen populations across a region.
Does mixing fungicides delay resistance?
Mixing two active ingredients from different FRAC groups can delay resistance by reducing selection pressure on each individual group — a resistant mutant to ingredient A is likely still sensitive to ingredient B. This is the rationale for triazole + SDHI products. However, mixing two actives from the same FRAC group (e.g. two SDHIs) provides no resistance management benefit and accelerates selection. The benefit of mixing also depends on relative doses — mixtures at low dose of each component may provide less disease control without meaningfully reducing selection pressure. FRAC Monograph 1 ↗ covers the theoretical and practical basis for fungicide resistance management.
What is the AHDB fungicide performance trials network?
The AHDB fungicide performance trials network ↗ runs replicated field trials at multiple sites across UK cereal-growing regions each season. Trials compare individual fungicide active ingredients and commercial products at disease-challenged locations, providing efficacy data that reflects current pathogen sensitivity in UK populations — more relevant than manufacturer data from controlled conditions or other geographies. Annual results are published in the fungicide performance summaries and should be the primary reference for UK programme design. See also the fungicide resistance in Septoria article.